The Green Nimby’s dilemma
Having just sailed through this beautiful part of the world, I can’t help feeling that a sensible middle ground has been reached with this week’s decision. Although it isn’t really a wooden boat story, the philosophical, economic and moral choices around sustainability and “amenity” (aethetics) tend to be front of mind for a wooden boat enthusiasts.
On the 19th December Energy Minister Chris Bowen to declare Gippsland as Australia's first offshore wind zone. Mr Bowen also confirmed new parameters to a zone previously proposed in the consultation period.
South Gippsland has been removed from the region's offshore wind zone, which now spans from south-east of Wilson's Promontory to Orbost.
Turbines can only be placed a minimum of 10 kilometres from the shore between Port Albert and Orbost, instead of the 5 kilometres that was previously declared.
"I am declaring the area east of Wilsons Promontory, not the area west of Wilsons Promontory in response to community concerns, environmental concerns and feedback," Mr Bowen said.
"The area did not receive the same level of community support as the proposal east and there's also environmental concerns with the famous orange-bellied parrot which need to be worked through."
But Mr Bowen did not rule out the potential for South Gippsland to be reinstated in the plan.
"I look forward to working with Lily D'Ambrosio and the Victorian government to further consider that area west of Wilsons Promontory over the coming 12 months to see if those community concerns can be dealt with and environmental concerns can be dealt with," he said.
He said it was a major milestone in delivering 2 gigawatts of offshore wind energy by 2032.
He said the target was to increase that to 4 gigawatts by 2035 and deliver 9 gigawatts of offshore wind energy by 2040.
The Victorian government has set the same targets.
Waratah Bay resident Robert Boelen co-founded community organisation Responsible Renewables with to push against wind turbines in waters near South Gippsland.
He had been calling for wind turbines to be placed further away from the shore than the initially-proposed 6 kilometres.
He said the outcome exceeded his expectations.
"It won't intrude on the Prom, the other new part is still far, far away enough from the Prom," he said.
"It doesn't include Corner Inlet or Snake Island and any of those, it's still far enough away to be virtually non-intrusive as far as the Prom is concerned."
